FIX
Another school I did not have but is found in the 2013 History of Fountain County, Indiana p 101 - and was in Logan Township, northeast of Attica about "2 1/2 miles on the north side of River Road."
From a collection of photographs from "Attica of Yesteryear" consisting of pictures that were collected by the Attica Sesquicentennial History Committee and Jeff Bossaer. Thanks Jeff!