ST NICHOLAS GERMAN LUTHERAN CEMETERY
Page 1 of 2 - WEST HALF

In 1986, Helen Moore prepared a report on the three Peppertown cemeteries: the Old Public Cemetery, the German Lutheran Church Cemetery and the New Cemetery. Helen was a member of the Indiana State Board of the Indiana German Heritage Society. Her relatives came directly to Peppertown from Germany in 1849, and she has relatives buried in the Old Public Cemetery. These listings are based on her report and were originally posted on Larry Christensen's website on AOL. Because AOL closed their home pages service in 2008, we have reproduced as much of the listings as we could reconstruct.

St Nicholas Page 2

Cemeteries A-G   Cemeteries H-R   Cemeteries S-Z
Cemetery Index
HOME

New Lot
Numbering
System 		Old Lot
Numbering
System 		Surname
[Maiden Name] 		First Name/s Birth Death Other Information
1
 
TEUFEL
Adam
1887
1888
Infant
1
  
UNKNOWN
     
Unmarked stone, possibly for an infant
1
            
1
            
2
41
HORSTMAN
William H.
1868
1935, March 18
Died at About Age 66
Heart Attack
2
41
HORSTMAN
[CHRISTIAN]
Christina
1835, April 28
1913, March 19
  
2
41
HOSE
[______]
Mother
1858
1922
Need her given and maiden names
2
41
HOSE
Henry
1847
1928
  
2
41
HOSE
Frank
1881
1926
  
3
40
SCHUNEMAN
Manda
      
3
40
          
3
40
          
3
40
          
4
37
WOLF
Earl Dewey
1897, April 9
1925, November 14
Parents: John WOLF and Lucinda ______
4
37
WOLF
[______]
Lucinda
(or Luzenda)
1855, April 17
1920, September 18
Husband: John WOLF, born June 1851
4
37
WOLF
Ray "Buddy"
1892, May
  
Parents: John WOLF and Lucinda ______
4
37
METCALF
Harold
1947, March 25
1968, March 12
Veteran, Viet Nam
Battery C., 8th Battalion, 4th Artillery
5
36
STOVER
Carl
      
5
36
          
5
36
          
5
36
          
6
 
SCHLIGEL
Maggie
1869
1898
  
6
            
6
            
6
            
7
39
WOLF
Henry
      
7
39
          
7
39
          
7
39
          
8
38
KOEHLER
Louis
[1881, June 20?]
1953, September 19
Parents: Vitus KOEHLER? and Mary Elizabeth SCHIRER?
8
38
KOEHLER
John
[1874, June 24?]
  
Parents: Vitus KOEHLER? and Mary Elizabeth SCHIRER?
8
38
          
8
38
          
9
 
STIRN
Louis
Friedrich
1857
1932, November 6 [not July 20]
Wife: Margaret B. TEUFEL
He Died at Age 75
9
  
STIRN
[TEUFEL]
Margaret
1863
[Not 1868]
1951, November 5
Husband: Louis Friedrich STIRN
Parents: John TEUFEL and Elizabeth ______
She Died at Age 88
9
  
STIRN
Lula A. (Emilia)
1899, July 30
    
9
  
STIRN
[BRACK]
Wilhelmine
1885
1961
  
10
           
10
            
10
            
10
            
11
           
11
            
11
            
11
            
12
 
UNKNOWN
     
Hobo buried here
12
            

Row 2 - West Half


New Lot
Numbering
System		 Old Lot
Numbering
System		 Surname
[Maiden Name]		 First name/s Birth Death Other Information
13
           
13
            
14
           
14
            
14
            
14
            
15
 
STIRN
Louis F.
1879
1946, March 3
Parents: Henry STIRN and Martha Elizabeth ROEMER [?]
15
  
STIRN
Anna M.
1884, February 7
1966, March 8
Died at Age 82
Apparently Never Married
Parents: Henry STIRN and Martha Elizabeth ROEMER [?]
15
            
15
            
16
 
STIRN
Carl F.
1888, June 30
1986, March 13
  
16
  
STIRN
[LUCK]
Katherine E.
1900, January 12
1931, September 29
  
16
            
16
            
17
32
BECHT
Jesse
      
17
32
          
17
32
          
17
32
          
18
 
WOLF
Charles
    
? A Charles WOLF married an Elizabeth HOSE. Is this the same?
18
  
WOLF
[Not known]
1813, October 13
1884
  
18
  
WOLF
Mary Elizabeth
1870
1980, September 30
  
18
  
WOLF
George Karl
1807, November 10
    
19
6
WOLF
Eugene Charles
1829, September 9
1829, September 28
Infant
19
6
WOLF
Roy
1918, April 21
1918, April 21
Infant
19
6
          
19
6
          
20
5
WOLF
Karl
1845, March 11
1880, August 22
Veteran.
20
5
WOLF
Elizabeth
1844
Plot List: 1920
[Alpha List: 1940]
  
20
5
          
20
5
          
21
4
STIRN
Andrew
      
21
4
WAMBACH
Anna Catharina
1817, October 18
1898, August 4
Husband: John WAMBACH, Born about 1822?
21
4
WAMBACH
Johann
1831, December 1 [1900 Census]
[or 1822?]
Plot List: 1907, December 12
[Alpha List: 1905]
  
21
4
STIRN
Johann (John) Andrew
1848, January 27
1900, June 22
  
21
4
STIRN
Martha Elizabeth
1852, February 28
1927, December 11
  
22
3
REIFEL
Michael
1832, December 29
1921, June 18
Wife: Wilhelmina DOEBLING
Parents: Henry REIFEL and Margaret DIETRICH
22
3
REIFEL
[DOEBLING]
Wilhelmina
1836, March 5
1897, August 20
Husband: Michael REIFEL
Parents: Casper DOEBLING and Mary ______
22
3
          
22
3
          
23
2
ROEMER
Anna Martha
1816, April 10
1888, February 24
Husband: Heinrich ROEMER
23
2
ROEMER
Heinrich
1818, August 26
1891, August 13
Wife: Anna Martha
23
2
ROEMER
Justus
Tombstone: 1852, July 14
1895, June 10
Wife: Margaret [REIFEL?] ROEMER
Parents: Note: Justus Roemer is not John Roemer--John was Sheriff of Franklin County, died 1922, February 8, and is buried elsewhere.
23
2
ROEMER
[REIFEL?]
Margaret (Maggie)
1859, January 18
1935, July 19
Husband: Justus ROEMER
24
1
REIFEL
Anna G.
1847, January 12
[Not January 2]
1889, February 1
[Or 1887?]
Note: Mrs. Darlene Palmer says that these dates match those of her great-grandmother, Anna Elizabeth [ROEMER] ELLERMAN, the first wife of Christian ELLERMAN, who was born 1840, April 10. Need some local help!
24
1
REIFEL
Theobald (Draft)
1842, March 5
[or May 5]
1876, March 1
  
24
1
ELLERMAN
Anna
  
1965, October
No Age Given
24
1
          

Row 3 - West Half


New Lot
Numbering
System		 Old Lot
Numbering
System		 Surname
[Maiden Name]		 First name/s Birth Death Other Information
25
12
HANNEBAUM
[WULBER]
Catherine Margaret "Kate"
1842, September 28
1929, August 7
Husband: Henry HANNEBAUM
Parents: Henry and Mary WULBER
25
12
HANNEBAUM
Johann Heinrich "Henry"
1827, May 5
[Not 1825]
1875, August 11
Wife: Catherine WULBER
Parents: J. Friedrich HANNEBAUM and Catherine BREDENWISCHER
25
12
          
25
12
          
26
11
REIFEL
Conrad
1840, February 22
1917, August 13
Wife: Louisa KOERNER
Parents: George Heinrich REIFEL and Margaret ______
26
11
REIFEL
Catherine Christina
1851, July 7
1893, February 23
[or 1898]
Parents: George Heinrich REIFEL and Margaret ______
26
11
REIFEL
George Heinrich
1805, April 14
1887, November 4
Wife: Margaret ______
26
11
REIFEL
George Philip
1855
[November 1854 on 1900 Census]
1933, November 16
He Died at Age 78
Wife: Catherine L. HORSTMAN
Father: Philip REIFEL?
26
11
PEPPER
Bobby
1934
1934
Infant son.
Parents: William Frederick PEPPER and Kate REIFEL
27
10
STIRN
William A., Sr.
(Wilhelm Andrew)
1874, May 5
1968, May 17
Wife: Augusta K. PEPPER
Parents: Henry STIRN and Martha Elizabeth ROEMER [?]
27
10
STIRN
[PEPPER]
Augusta K. "Gussie"
1882, May 7
1965, April 5
Died at Age 82
Husband: William A. STIRN, Sr.
Parents: Louis R. PEPPER and Caroline HEINEMAN
27
10
PEPPER
Will
[About 1865?]
  
[Parents: August PEPPER and Eliza HANNEBAUM]
27
10
REIFEL
[HORSTMAN]
Catherine L.
1856, April 17
1935, April 9
Husband: George Philip REIFEL
Daughter: Kate [REIFEL] PEPPER
28
9
KIRSCHBAUM
[______]
Magdalena "Lena"
1824, January 5
1895, May 24
[Alpha List: March]
Husband: Probably John Michael KIRSCHBAUM
28
9
KIRSCHBAUM
John Michael
1812
1876, September 18
Wife: Probably Magdalena KIRSCHBAUM
28
9
KIRSCHBAUM
Maria
      
28
9
KIRSCHBAUM
Johann [G?]
      
28
9
KIRSCHBAUM
[Unknown]
  
1895, April 17
  
28
9
KIRSCHBAUM
Carolina
  
1901, August 8
  
28
9
KIRSCHBAUM
George Frank Walter
1899, August 4
    
28
9
KIRSCHBAUM
Frank
1899, June 19
1904, May 28
  
29
8
KOERNER
Matheus
      
29
8
KOERNER
Dora M.
1826, September 24
1881, September 28
  
29
8
{KOERNER}
{PEPPER}
Not sure which is maiden name
Charlotte
1800, January 12
1866, January 3
Lived with John C. KOERNER and his wife, Eliza ______ in 1860.
Is she John's sister or Eliza's mother?
29
8
KOERNER
[______]
Louisa
1825, August 12
1871, August 17
Second wife of John C. KOERNER
30
7
KOERNER
Gustav A.
1855, March 19
1860, February 15
Child.
Parents: John C. KOERNER and Eliza ______
30
7
KOERNER
Henry Albert
1857, March 13
1860, January 12
Child.
Parents: John C. KOERNER and Eliza ______
30
7
KOERNER
John C.
1812, February 14
1892, July 17
First wife: Eliza, died 1860-1869
Second wife: Louisa
30
7
          
31
7
          
31
7
          
31
7
          
31
7
          
32
27
MOHR
Conrad
1842, August 4
1914, March 26
Wife: Elizabeth BOLTZ
Parents: Jacob L. MOHR and Eva Catherine REIFEL
32
27
MOHR
[BOLTZ]
Elizabeth
1850, December 21
1925, October 22
Husband: Conrad MOHR
Parents: Georg M. BOLTZ and Eva POSTEL
32
27
          
32
27
          
33
28
ALLEY
William Arrington "Will"
1932
Plot list: 1907
[Alpha list: 1917, February 25]
Wife: Elizabeth ______
Parents: David ALLEY and Rebecca JONES
33
28
ALLEY
[______]
Elizabeth
1933
19??
Husband: Will A. ALLEY
33
28
ALLEY
Elizabeth Christine
1869, June 6
1912, July 17
Inscription: Daughter
33
28
ALLEY
Hester
  
1950
  
33
28
ALLEY
Florence
      
34
43
WOLF
Herbert
      
34
43
          
34
43
          
34
43
          
35
           
35
            
35
            
35
            
36
 
JOHNSON
Roy
      
36
  
JOHNSON
Selvia
      
Thanks to Helen Moore and Larry Christensen for this listing.

Cemeteries A-G   Cemeteries H-R   Cemeteries S-Z
Cemetery Index
HOME

Copyright 2009 by Karen Creamer