From the 1900-01 Catalog of the New London Public Schools. NOTE: Handwritten comments in italics. Duplication of names as in original source.
| 1884 | |
| Taylor HOLLINGSWORTH | Kokomo |
| N.H. NEWLIN, M.D. | New London |
| 1885 | |
| Emma NEWLIN CLARK | New London |
| Rev. A.J. BROWN | Indianapolis |
| Ada G. COSAND BROWN | Indianapolis |
| Jenny SMALL | Elwood |
| Mary F. COSAND HADLEY | Marion |
| Addison TUCKER (deceased) | |
| 1886 | |
| Prof. C.E. COSAND | Chicago, Ill. |
| Emma Clark | |
| D.W. TUCKER | Poplar Grove |
| W.E. LINDLEY | Rialto Cal. |
| 1887 | |
| Lizzie ARNETT | Kokomo |
| O.A. Thomas | Kokomo |
| T.E. NEWLIN | New London |
| Collie Hoves [?] | |
| 1888 | |
| Lydia PEACOCK | Kokomo |
| D.E. SMALL | Kokomo |
| Will PEACOCK | Indianapolis |
| Florence HAWORTH NEWLIN | New London |
| Bell NEWLIN SMALL | Kokomo |
| 1889 | |
| M. Ella NEWLIN TAYLOR | New London |
| Elma MENDENHALL HOLLET | Huntington |
| 1890 | |
| Ada PEACOCK | Kokomo |
| Milton SMALL | New London |
| Miss HUNT | |
| Maud E. BROWN | New London |
| Nora T. COSAND | New London |
| Howard DIXON | Russiaville |
| C.G. TAYLAR | New London |
| Ella Newlin | |
| A.C. WOOLY | ------ |
| Jesse L. COPPOCK | -----, Minn. |
| 1891 | |
| Curtis TUCKER | Kokomo |
| Mattie KENWORTHY | |
| Ratie KENWORTHY TAYLOR | New London |
| H.M. STOUT | Galveston |
| Will THOMAS | West Middleton |
| Edna CARPENTER | Elwood |
| L.P. HAWORTH | New London |
| Ella QUAKENBUSH | |
| Violetta COSAND | New London |
| 1892 | |
| F.S. HOBSON | New London |
| Zella HART | |
| M.S. KENWORTHY | New London |
| N.H. MENDENHALL | New London |
| Chas. E. GRANTHAM | Battle Creek, Mich |
| C.E. ENDICOTT | Jeffersonville |
| Elizabeth Massmutte [?] | |
| Omer GRANTHAM | Battle Creek Mich. |
| 1893 | |
| Prof. Albert HANSON | Wabash |
| C.C. WRIGHT | Cando N.D. |
| C.L. MCDANIEL | Ridgeway |
| A.E. JONES | New London |
| Henry NEWLIN | New London |
| Myrtle SCHOOLY NEWLIN | New London |
| Lizzie THOMAS BRUBAKER | Burlington |
| 1894 | |
| Emmo SIMONS | New London |
| Lena TUCKER GORDON | New London |
| Carl EIKENBERRY | Russiaville |
| Metta MCDANIEL | Kokomo |
| Enid MARIS | Russiaville |
| 1895 | |
| Violetta COSAND | New London |
| Elizabeth HANSON | New London |
| Clara MENDENHALL | New London |
| C.V. HAWORTH | New London |
| Lizzie THOMAS BRUBAKER | Burlington |
| 1896 | |
| Alta ALEXANDER HART | Texas |
| Cora GRUBBS | New London |
| Florence HOOVER | New London |
| Alice JONES | New London |
| J.M. STOUT | Richmond |
| L.E. COSAND | New London |
| Laura HANSON | |
| H.C. HART | New London |
| E.T. KENWORTHY | New London |
| Louie THOMPSON | |
| Vertia STOUT EIKENBERRY | Russiaville |
| 1897 | |
| Lew JORDAN | Russiaville |
| Ova BUTTER | |
| Frank ENDICOTT | LaFayette |
| Clarence EDWARDS | New London |
| Lettie KENWORTHY | |
| May FORTNER | New London |
| Melvin GORDON | Russiaville |
| Victor COOPER | Russiaville |
| L.W. STOUT | New London |
| Dora MANUEL [?] | |
| Geo. O. JONHSON [sic] | Russiaville |
| 1898 | |
| Otis TUCKER | New London |
| Clyde SHEARER | New London |
| Pearley SIMONS | New London |
| Martha MOSS | New London |
| Hal E. TATE | Shanhai [sic Shanghai] |
| Maggie JOHNSON | West Middleton |
| Bertha WRIGHT | Russiaville |
| Clint HART | New London |
| Laura HANSON COSAND | New London |
| 1899 | |
| Bertha K. BOWEN MCCOY | New London |
| Lois FARLOWE | New London |
| Minnie MCCOY | New London |
| Mattie CUNNINGHAM | New London |
| Corydon RICH | New London |
| Joseph CUNNINGHAM | New London |
| Mattie JOHNSON | West Middleton |
| Ethel LONG | West Middleton |
| Mary MOSS | -----, Mo. |
| Peachy SIMONS | New London |
| Claud PHILPOT | Yeddo |