Horace Pinney and sons
William, Horace and David Pinney


Pinney Farm - Clinton Township - From 1874 LaPorte County Atlas
For Larger Image click on picture. (Hit your back button to return to page.)

Pinney and Associated Families with
LaPorte County, Indiana Connections

Study compiled by D. West and updated 29 June 2003.

According to Genealogy of the Pinney Family in America; Author, Laura Young Pinney b. 1849 - published in San Francisco, CA by the Harr Wagner Pub. Co in 1924 Horace , (son of Lieutenant Abraham, son of Captain Abraham, son of Nathaniel, son of Nathaniel, second son of Humphrey Pinne,) and the father of the above 3 brothers arrived in LaPorte county, Indiana about 1837 with his Wife Nancy Snavely whom he had married in 1811 in Virginia and then went to Jackson County, Ohio before coming to LaPorte County and settling in the Clinton Township area.

Horace died in 1839 and Nancy soon after in 1841, they are both buried in Westville Cemetery, LaPorte Co., IN. They had seven children: David born about 1812 , Horace, b. 1817, William b. 1819, Mary b. 1821 (married Phineas Small June 25, 1840 in LaPorte County), Harvey, born 1825 and died in 1834 and Lois, born in 1827 married Jacob Thornbush in LaPorte County May 4, 1843.

1. David, died at the age of 34 years (Aug 11, 1847)
Synopsis for David, b. 9 Nov 1812 - (eldest son of Horace , son of Lieutenant Abraham, son of Captain Abraham, son of Nathaniel, son of Nathaniel, second son of Humphrey Pinne,) evidently had his life cut short as he is buried in Westville Cemetery as are his parents, two younger brothers and many others connected with the Pinney surname. He may have indeed resided in Pine Grove, Gallio County, Ohio; as I have seen written in some family histories, but 3 males between the ages of 20 and 30 appear on the 1840 LaPorte County census with Nancy Snavely Pinney and I believe him to be one of these. This accompanied with the fact of his tombstone in Westville Cemetery leaves me little doubt. David had two children; Abraham and Aurora, I have nothing further on them. Also in the year 1835 it is noted in the old settler's list for Clinton Township that Horace Pinney Sr., Horace Pinney Jr., Wm. Pinney and David Pinney were listed.

2. Horace, b. 14 Sept 1817
Horace, (son of Horace, son of Lieutenant Abraham, son of Captain Abraham, son of Nathaniel, son of Nathaniel, second son of Humphrey Pinne,) married Angeline Haskell in LaPorte County May 4, 1843. Angeline (Haskell) Pinney b. 4 Feb 1827 in Erie County, Pennsylvania and arriving in LaPorte Co., about 1834 appears on the old settlers listing. She was the daughter of James & Betsey Haskell and wife of Horace Pinney. Horace was born about 14 Sep 1817 and died 20 Apr. 1880. Angeline died 20 Sep 1872 and both husband and wife are buried in Westville Cemetery. After the death of Angeline F., Horace married Nancy Dowd on the 14 May 1874. This Nancy, may have gone to Iowa after the death of Horace, however, I have no concrete proof of this.

Horace and Angeline had several children. They were :

I.  Jay was born 2 Jan 1847 and died 7-11-1937 cemetery record shows birth as 1/20/1847. He married Laurie Ellen (Nellie) Hopkins, daughter of David H. Hopkins. born 2-24-1857 and they were married on the 17 Jun 1874 in Porter County, IN. In 1900 Jay and his wife are in Stafford County, Kansas. Laura died 10-9-1926 in Ford, Ford Co. Kansas. Jay and his wife Laura Ellen are laid to rest at Riverview Cemetery, Ford County, Kansas. Cemetery name also known as Ford Cemetery.

II. Jane (Jennie) b. 20 April 1850 married Clayton S. Goodwin 20 April 1868. He was a Civil War Veteran that had served in the Company K the 73rd Indiana Infantry. Clayton died about 1917. and she died at the age of 91 in May1941. Both buried in Westville Cemetery. By 1900 Jane (Jennie) has given birth to 10 children, 8 of which are still living.

III. Nora (Shown as Janurah in some documentation) b. 4 Sept 1852 married Thaddeus H. Forbes 26 Jun 1875, He was born Coburg Upper Canada and the son of J. R. & Martha (Pettit) Forbes.
He was b. Aug 20, 1851 d. Feb 23, 1923. Nora died Jun 13, 1919.
Both are buried in Westville. See: Counties of Porter and Lake, Indiana, Historical and Biographical, "Goodspeed and Blanchard 1882 page 334 Washington Township.

IV. Kay, born 16 November 1854 and married Eva C. Crawley 8 Apr 1873 in LaPorte County, IN. Kay died young and is buried in Westville Cemetery. He died the 11 July 1888.

V. Eli or also known as Ell, born 6 May 1856 married Rachel. Josephine "Josie". Hall 15 May 1883 in LaPorte County, IN. Rachel Hall born 1860 and died 1940. Ell would die in 1945. Their children, according to the 1900 census are: Marie b. Aug 1884 later married Edwin Eaton and they are both buried in Union Mills Cemetery, LaPorte County, IN. ; Cora L b. Aug 1885 later married Hettie Mitzner ; Ethel J. b. Nov 1886; Harry H. b. Feb 1888; Dortha J b. Jan 1893; Birtha A b. Dec 1894; Lois Ruth. b. Aug 1897 and Rollin H. b. Apr 1899. They are living in Clinton township, LaPorte County in the 1900 Census, 1920 we find them in Clinton twp with Bertha, Ruth, Rollin and Louise (later married a Collins and she died December 1948) and also seen there in 1930 census with his wife and two of their children - Rollin age 30 and Louise age 27. In 1920 daughter Ethel is living single in Dewey Township. This family is farming the land for an occupation. Ell and his wife Rachel are buried in Westville Cemetery. Dorothy b. 27 Jan 1893 later married a Mr. Louis W. Guse (b. 5 Apr 1890) and they had at least two children. Dorothy died 12 Oct 1992. Dorothy and Louis are buried in Hanna Cemetery.
Their daughter Ruth married Mr. Delmar F. Mitzner, son of Mr. and Mrs. H.A. Mitzner on 29 Nov 1923 in Wanatah.

VI. Emra 15 October 1858 and died 16 Mar 1859 buried Westville.

VII. Erastus. born 3 Feb 1861 he died in Ventura County CA 18 Jan 1959. In 1900 we find Erastus in Stafford County, Kansas as is his older brother Jay. then in 1920 Erastus is in Albuquerque, Bernallio, NM but by 1930 Erastus and his wife Florence are living in Arizona, Coconino Co., Grand Canyon. He is working as a baggageman for the railroad and is 69 years old.

VIII. Ellsworth born 7April 1863 and died 27 June 1922, burial in Westville. By the 1900 census he is living with his cousin Edwin Slocum, Edwin's wife Jane and family in Clinton township. In 1910 Ellsworth is living with the Abraham Aker and his wife in Cass Township, La Porte County, Indiana ED # 80 page 6 A. Ellsworth is a boarder and working as a farm laborer. He is living in Indiana Village for Epileptics, Prairie township, Henry County, Indiana in 1920; ED #73, page 12B, it appears that Ellsworth never married.

IX. Lois A. born 2 July 1865 and died 11 Jul 1953. Lois never married and is buried in Westville Cemetery. In 1910 Lois is working as a Music Teacher in Center Township, Porter County, Indiana and is boarding at the home of  the John L Beyl family on West Chicago Street. Buried in Westville as is her sister Emma.

X. Emma Rosanna or Rosanna Emma b. 30 Sep 1867 and died 27 Dec 1951. Occupation was that of a bookkeeper. Emma never married. In 1910 Emma is living with sister Nora and Nora's husband Thaddeus Forbes in Valparaiso, Indiana on Chicago Street. In 1920 after Nora's death, Emma is still living at the same address and household with her sister's widower. She is a bookkeeper for the Thrift Company. Emma can be found living with her sister Lois in Valparaiso, Porter Co., Indiana in 1930. Emma is working as a bank cashier.

3. William  (3rd son of Horace, son of Lieutenant Abraham, son of Captain Abraham, son of Nathaniel, son of Nathaniel, second son of Humphrey Pinne,) b. 28 July 1819. married Cynthia Long in LaPorte County, IN on Dec 23, 1841

Cynthia (Long) Pinney also appears on the old settlers listing as being b. in Jackson Co., VA on 20 Sep 1822 and coming to LaPorte in October of 1836. Cynthia was the daughter of Gideon and Elizabeth Long.
She married William Pinney in LaPorte County 23 Dec 1841 and they settled into the Clinton Twp in LaPorte County as did Horace, William's older brother, and their families. Many of the members of all three above families and their associated families are buried in Westville Cemetery, New Durham Twp, LaPorte County, Indiana.

William and Cynthia had the following children:

I. Elizabeth Nancy was born Oct 6, 1842 married Warren Cole 19 Nov 1862. Warren was born in New York state on Dec 3, 1838 and died Mar 10, 1898. Both are buried in Westville Cemetery. To this marriage were born the following children; Cole, Alice A. Cole, born about 1864 married William J. Young in Lake County on the 27 May 1886 she died 1932 - both are buried in Westville Cemetery as are Alice' brother and sister; William Zina Cole - b. Jul 7, 1866 d. Jul 25, 1916: Bertha M. Cole b. Sept 23, 1870 d. Oct 20, 1870. In 1880 this family had moved to Lake County, Indiana, where Warren was employed as a Watchmaker, Jeweler.

II. Harvey Wright Pinney born 15 Jul 1844 , married Margaret A. Kelley in LaPorte Co., IN 06 Oct 1868. His name is misspelled in the WPA marriage index as Binney. They had eleven children. IN 1870 Harvey is living in Essex Township, Porter County, Indiana. Some of the children born to this marriage were: Adella L. b, about 1870, Lillian O., Perry F., Edna L., William H., Mary A., Leonard L. See the 1880 on line Census from the Latter Day Saints site for information on the ages of these children, etc. They are back in LaPorte County in 1880. Harvey W. Pinney headed west some time after 1883. If we look at the census and birth's of his various children, it appears that Harvey W Pinney's wife, Margaret had 11 children and 8 of which are surviving, so she states on the 1900 census for South Dakota, Tripp Co, Wright Voting Precinct. In 1910 we find Harvey and Margaret in Tripp County, SD , Wright Voting Precinct.

Harvey;s son, Frank (Percy Franklin Pinney) in 1900 is living with his wife Cora and they are recently married. They are living in City of Omaha Nebraska. Douglas County. Name is misspelled on this census as Penney. Their divorced son
Frank (Percy Franklin) is living with them in 1910. Frank is 38 years old.

And in the 1920 census Clarence yet another child of Harvey and Margaret is living with his mother and she is widowed and living next door to her son William and his wife and children.
Leonard, another son of Harvey and Margaret has passed away before 1920 and his wife(Victoria Lawrence) Pinney and children living first in Cedar County, NE and then moving to Douglas Co., NE.
Victoria later went to California and passed away there in 1944.

III. James Andrew b. 27 June and died same year on 14 July 1846 he shares a tombstone with his brother, Elvin Clinton who was b. 17 July 1860 and evidently did not live long. James and Elvin are definitely the sons of William and not a James Pinney as they appear one listing that I viewed.

IV. William Esli Pinney  b. abt 10 Nov 1847. In about 1875 William E. Pinney (William, Horace Sr.) married Finnette (Nettie) Morrison daughter of John McCord and Susan (Courtney Blair) Morrison b. Jan 1848. In 1890 William is the Pres. State Bank Valparaiso. In the 1900 census for Center Township, Porter County, Indiana we find William, his wife Finnette, their only child Myra Finette Pinney b. July of 1880 and their nephew Guy are living with them along with William's mother-in-law, Finette (Morrison) Pinney's mother, Susan Morrison who states she is a widow and b. March 1822 and is 78 years old and from Ohio as she so states her parents were from Kentucky and Pennsylvania. In 1910 William is living with his daugher on W. Lafayette street in Valparaiso. William's occupation was that of a banker.
   Ref: History of LaPorte County - Packard page 267:
A special election was held in October 1873, for Prosecuting attorney to fill a vacancy occasioned by the reorganization of the courts of the State. The candidates were James A Crawley and William E. Pinney of LaPorte, and George Ford of South Bend. Ford received one hundred and thirteen votes, Pinney two hundred and twenty five, and Crawley one thousand one hundred and eighty.

This William and his daughter Myra will later donate land to Purdue University for their Agricultural Center. Unproven at this writing, but all references seem to indicate that Myra married Ainsworth Clark b. Montcalm County, Michigan in about 1877 to Ethan J and Alice J. Clark out of the state of New York. Myra states on the 1930 census report for Cook Co., IL, ED 208 that she was married at age 38, she is then 50 years of age, this would mean that Ainsworth and Myra were married about 1918. There are two children listed on the 1930 census; a daughter, Ruth age 7 and a son, John M. age 6 both born Illinois.

V. Perry Guilford b. 3 Feb 1850, appears in the 1900 Fredonia, Wilson County, Kansas census with his wife Ella b. Illinois and two sons, Walter born Feb 1887 and Warren born June 1892 in Kansas. US Fed. Census, Center township, Wilson Co., KS pg 23A. Son, Guy, born in 4 September 1880 is already out of the home and living with his uncle William E. Pinney in Porter County, Indiana, Clinton Township. Later on Perry went to California and appears there on the1920 census with his son Guy L. Pinney (Guy is 39 years of age) and in the 1930 census Perry appears at the age of 80. They are living in Los Angeles, CA.

Guy, on his own later headed to Los Angeles California.
In 1910 Guy is joined by his brother Walter, they are both single, Guy is 31 and Walter is 23 and the are living as Lodgers on South Main Street in Los Angeles, CA. Later in 1920, his father would join him in the 1920 census CA, Los Angeles ED 190 - They are living on or near S. Vermont Avenue. Guy S. Pinney appears as being 39 in this census.
Guy S. Perry appears on the California death index as being born 4 Sep 1880 in Kansas and dying
3 Apr 1946 in Riverside, California. Mother's maiden name being Stratton.

VI. Herman Franklin b. 26 Mar 1852. In 1900 Herman, of Frank H, as he is placing on his census report for 1900 is living in Wilson County, Kansas.,

VII. Lois Charlotte b. 1 Sept 1854, Married Jeduthan D. Clark on 26 June 1875. Jeduthan was born Oct 6, 1851 and died 1922. Lois Charlotte died in 1948. Both are buried in Westville Cemetery, Westville, LaPorte County, IN.

VIII. Elvin Clinton 17 July 1860 (see James Andrew Pinney, Elvin's brother listed above.) May have died in 1862, unproven by this author.

4. Mary Pinney, (daughter of Horace, son of Lieutenant Abraham, son of Captain Abraham, son of Nathaniel, son of Nathaniel, second son of Humphrey Pinne,) w/o Phineas Small b. Ohio Nov 27, 1821 m. Phineas in LaPorte Co., Indiana 25 June 1840. They had Lois, Nancy, Eunice, Orange L., (b. April 1844) Betsy, Riley, Henderson, Harrison Buried in Westville Cemetery with the following information:
Small, Phineas b. South Carolina Nov 9, 1805 d. Jul 28,1896 Small, Mary w/o Phineas b. Ohio Nov 27, 1821 d. Nov 9, 1900

5. Lois b. abt 1827 (daughter of Horace, son of Lieutenant Abraham, son of Captain Abraham, son of Nathaniel, son of Nathaniel, second son of Humphrey Pinne,) married in LaPorte County on 5 Dec 1848 Mr. Jacob Thornburgh (b. abt 1826) Their child Willie E. (William E. Thornburgh) appears on the 1870 Federal Census for LaPorte County Westville City, pg 283a Indiana as being 17 years of age.) By 1880 Jacob, Lois and William are in Franklin, Jackson Co., KS. Jacob's occupation is a farmer.

Please note that this is NOT necessarily all of the children of Horace Sr. and Nancy (Snavely) Pinney But these children fit the ages of the children that accompanied them to Indiana when looking at the 1840 LaPorte County Indiana Federal Census reports.

Connections in LaPorte and Porter County

William E. Pinney, son of William Pinney, and his daughter Myra F. P. Clark gave the Pinney farm to Purdue University and the people of Indiana in 1919. The marker in front of the original Pinney homestead reads:
"The farm is dedicated to the advancement of agricultural and the enrichment of country life."

References used to compile this work study were:
History of Ancient Windsor, Vol II, Surnames O-Q page 615 and 619
Genealogy of the Pinney Family. By Laura Young Pinney. San Fransico, 1924. (61page total.):pages 44 to 46
Federal Census Reports
1874 Atlas picture of Pinney Homstead submitted by Gloria Arndt.

Return to LaPorte County Biographies