- Iddings, George W - 1940
- Idrogo, Irma (Arizola) - 2018
- Ignace, Stephen II - 2017
- Ingalls, Rev. Wisher K. - 1960
- Ingels, Logan M. - 1957
- Ingle, Mrs. Belle - 1940
- Ingledue, Flossie - 1940
- Ingram, Frederick G. - 2017
- Irven, Jacob Marc - 2018
- Irving, Dewey Dale - 1961
- Isenbarger, Bonnie L (Brubaker) - 2018
- Isenhour, Ireneus - 1909
- Isenhour, Mrs. Phoebe Caroline - 1919