| Spouse # 1 | Spouse # 2 | Date |
|---|
| Underwood | Alfred | Walker | Sara Ann | 09-23-1832 |
| Underwood | Amy | Self | Philip | 11-11-1834 |
| Underwood | Charity | Cosgrove | Patrick | 12-13-1839 |
| Underwood | Delitha | Self | Thomas | 11-07-1828 |
| Underwood | Elizabeth Ann | Harmon | William W | 01-16-1842 |
| Underwood | Henry | Mc Cracken | Nancy | 01-25-1838 |
| Underwood | Isaac W | Chandler | Mary Ann | 11-13-1842 |
| Underwood | Lemuel | Cook | Polly | 10-21-1841 |
| Underwood | Margaret | Jenkins | Wesley | 12-27-1821 |
| Underwood | Mary | Wilson | Jesper | 11-10-1825 |
| Underwood | Mary Jane | Ferguson | Thomas J | 05-09-1844 |
| Underwood | Sarah M | Doan | Mahlon | 10-22-1850 |
| Underwood | Stephen | Henson | Nancy | 06-09-1842 |
| Underwood | Stephen | Cane | Elizabeth | 11-14-1850 |
| Underwood | Susannah | Dodds | David C | 11-18-1838 |